Dog Food Delivery · October 2026
Ollie vs The Farmer's Dog: Fresh Dog Food With Built-In Health Check-Ins
Ollie
The Farmer's Dog
Ollie delivers fresh dog food made from human-grade meat, fruit, vegetables and grains, with recipes developed with vet nutritionists and chefs. You can choose beef, chicken, lamb, turkey or pork, mix recipes, and pick a Full Fresh plan or a Half Fresh plan that tops up your dog's current food. Ollie also runs Health Check-ins to help owners keep an eye on their dog's condition over time.
The Farmer's Dog helped create the fresh dog food category. It makes human-grade recipes to human-grade safety standards, portions each plan to your dog's calorie needs, lists its recipes as AAFCO complete and balanced, and has board-certified nutritionists on staff. Alongside its original fresh food it now sells Instant Fresh, a shelf-stable option. Deliveries are timed to your dog's plan and you can cancel any time.
The real difference is in the extras: Ollie offers more ways to use fresh food and a built-in health check-in, while The Farmer's Dog keeps a focused, pre-portioned fresh plan.
| Ollie Our pick | The Farmer's Dog | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 9.7/10 · Outstanding | 9.6/10 · Excellent |
| Rank | #1 in Dog Food Delivery | #2 in Dog Food Delivery |
| Highlights |
|
|
| Get Deal | Get Deal |
Our verdict
Ollie is the better choice for most dog owners. The Half Fresh plan lets you add fresh food to your dog's existing diet rather than switching completely, which suits owners trying fresh food for the first time or feeding larger dogs. Five proteins give options for picky eaters and dogs that do better on one meat than another, and Health Check-ins add a simple way to track how your dog is doing between vet visits. That flexibility is why it leads our ranking.
The Farmer's Dog is the better pick if you want a tightly portioned, fully fresh diet with as little decision making as possible. Its plans are built around your dog's calorie needs, its nutritionists are on staff, and the shelf-stable Instant Fresh option helps for travel or limited freezer space.
Both use human-grade ingredients and personalised portions, so either is a solid step up in convenience. Any change in diet is best made gradually, and if your dog has a health condition, allergies or a prescribed diet, talk to your vet before switching food.
Get Deal — OllieRead the full reviews: Ollie review · The Farmer's Dog review · or see all our Dog Food Delivery picks.