The Super Nintendo had an enormous library, and almost every critic who ranks it ends up arguing over the same dozen games. Rather than add one more opinion to the pile, we combined eight published rankings from IGN, Nintendo Power, Game Informer, Complex, Esquire, Den of Geek, Destructoid and GamesRadar+, scored each list the same way and added up the results.
The outcome is a top 10 the critics broadly agree on: The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past finishes first by a single point over Chrono Trigger, with Super Metroid close behind. Each entry below gives the release details, how the game placed on each list, why critics rate it, and where you can still play it legally today.